Revive or Replace: Is It Cheaper To Buy New Or Take Care Of Your Current Vehicle?

Apr 2, 2024 | Maintenance

At High Road Automotive, we’ve always believed in providing our customers with exceptional service and valuable insights to make informed decisions about their vehicles. Recently, during conversations at an industry training event, our team stumbled upon an intriguing revelation—many people are considering buying new cars rather than reviving the cars they currently have, possibly because they haven’t considered the long-term financial implications of doing so.

In this blog, we’ll discuss recent industry trends and why maintaining your current vehicle could be a smarter financial choice in the long run. Additionally, we’ll go over when a new vehicle would make the most sense for your situation. As always, feel free to contact us or visit our shop for further education, insight, or an appointment.

The Average Repair Invoice vs. A Monthly New Car Payment

front of car headlight

Photo by Sarah Brown on Unsplash

Let’s dive into the numbers. Our research indicates that the average repair invoice at High Road Automotive typically ranges between 2-3 monthly car payments in 2024, depending on the car and the repair. Yes, you read that right – maintaining your current vehicle could cost you less than the monthly payments on a brand-new one!

Now, let’s address another elephant in the room–rising car prices. Over the past two decades, car prices have soared by a staggering 210%.

Why did this happen? With interest rates hovering around 2-3% in the past, made these price hikes more palatable for consumers. However, with interest rates on the rise, the landscape is shifting. You may find that the prices you find at the dealership or a car lot are nothing like the ones you were offered the last time you were car shopping.

New Isn’t Always Better

This brings us to the importance of customer education. Many of us were raised when low-interest rates made purchasing new vehicles seem like a no-brainer. However, with interest rates climbing, consumers must weigh their options carefully.

Repairing and maintaining your current vehicle offers a range of benefits that can make it a wise choice over purchasing a new car. Here are some reasons why opting for repairs might be the right decision for you:

  • Cost Savings: Repairing your current car is often more cost-effective than purchasing a new one. While buying a new vehicle incurs significant upfront costs, repairing your existing car allows you to address specific issues without the financial burden of a large purchase.
  • Extended Lifespan: Proper maintenance and timely repairs can prolong the lifespan of your vehicle. Addressing minor issues before they escalate can prevent more significant problems and keep your car running smoothly for years.
  • Familiarity and Comfort: Many drivers develop a sense of familiarity and attachment to their current vehicles. Repairing your car allows you to maintain this familiarity and continue enjoying its comfort and convenience without needing to adjust to a new vehicle.
  • Customization and Personalization: Over time, you may have customized or personalized your current car to suit your preferences. Whether through aftermarket upgrades or sentimental additions, repairing your existing vehicle allows you to preserve these customizations and maintain a vehicle that reflects your unique style and personality.
  • Environmental Considerations: Opting for repairs over purchasing a new car can have positive environmental implications. Extending the lifespan of your current vehicle reduces the demand for new car production, which in turn helps conserve resources and minimize environmental impact.
  • Lower Insurance Costs: Insurance premiums for new vehicles are often higher than for older ones. By repairing your current car instead of purchasing a new one, you can save money on insurance premiums, contributing to overall cost savings over time.
  • Convenience and Minimal Disruption: Repairing your current car allows you to avoid the hassle and disruption of shopping for a new vehicle. You don’t need to deal with the logistics of selling or trading in your old car, negotiate with dealerships, or adjust to a different vehicle.

By considering these benefits, you can decide whether repairing your current car aligns with your needs, preferences, and financial goals.

When A New Car Makes Sense

When deciding between repairing your current vehicle or investing in a new one, there are certain situations where purchasing a new car may be the more sensible choice. While we advocate for the value of maintaining and repairing your vehicle, there are circumstances where the cost of repairs may outweigh the benefits. Here’s a guide to help you determine when it might be time to consider buying a new car:

  • Cost of Repairs Exceeds Vehicle Value: When the cost of repairs surpasses the current market value of your car, it may be a sign that it’s time to part ways with your old vehicle.
  • Safety Concerns: If your car is experiencing significant safety issues that cannot be adequately addressed through repairs, such as structural damage or malfunctioning safety features, it’s crucial to prioritize your safety and consider purchasing a new, safer vehicle.
  • Desire for Modern Features: If you want to upgrade to a vehicle with the latest technology, improved fuel efficiency, and enhanced safety features, purchasing a new car may align better with your needs and preferences.

While repairing and maintaining your current vehicle can often be a cost-effective option, evaluating your specific circumstances and carefully weighing the pros and cons is essential. By considering factors such as repair costs, safety, performance, and personal preferences, you can make an informed decision that best suits your needs and budget.

The Verdict: Repairs May Save Your Money Long Term

At High Road Automotive, we’re not just about fixing cars but empowering our customers to make financially savvy choices. Consider this: opting for repairs instead of rushing into a new car purchase could save thousands of dollars in the long run.

So, the next time you’re faced with a hefty repair estimate, don’t write off your current vehicle just yet. Take a moment to consult our comparative analysis, weigh your options, and remember – at High Road Automotive, we’re here to help you navigate the maze of car expenses, one repair at a time. Come to High Road Automotive in Seattle, WA., and we’ll help you repair your vehicle, new or old. Please schedule an appointment today!

Recent Blog Posts

4 Must-Attend Events in Seattle This April!

4 Must-Attend Events in Seattle This April!

As April unfolds its petals in Seattle, the city bursts with a kaleidoscope of events beckoning exploration. Here are five standout gatherings destined to etch unforgettable memories: Seattle Cherry Blossom & Japanese Cultural Festival When: April 12th Where:...

5 Ways To Stay Safe Driving On Snowy Roads

5 Ways To Stay Safe Driving On Snowy Roads

Most of us haveof have been driving on Seattle’s snowy roads for more years than we can count–however, everyone needs a refresher now and then on safe driving! If anything, driving for an extended amount of time can make us more comfortable than we should be when...